From the same old set as the PCGS/CAC AU-58 1916-D Half I also have listed (if still available).  In this case, I have no problem with the assigned grade but chose not to send it to CAC due to just a bit of light chatter in the right-hand Obverse field.  As notoriously picky as John, et al. tend to be, I did not see fit to spend the bucks, but it might be worth it for someone else (coin guaranteed to never have been seen by CAC or CACG).  Nice bright flashy surfaces about 1/3 lightly toned in reddish-gray with some blue highlights.  Well struck with no noticeable defects and good eye appeal.

PCGS 6570.58/54288612