Certified PCGS AU-50, in my opinion this coin is clearly better than that - generally I would not send one of these in unless I thought it had a genuine shot at AU-58.  Original chocolate brown surfaces with plenty of obvious luster.  The Obverse die was just a bit older as it shows some fine die cracks and overall surface erosion.  Maybe that distracted the "children" at PCGS.  I have posted two Obverse images - the first shows the true color more accurately, the second may show the detail a bit better.  A nice coin to represent the Type.  This is priced at the equivalent of a AU-53; it is my opinion that this would have no problems at CAC. 

PCGS 3576.50/53954808