(Cross listed from ebay, for those who find their way here) Almost Uncirculated, in my opinion, an AU-50 for detail. Certified PCGS Details for what they called a "stain".  The only possibility of a "problem" I can see in that regard is a small dull area on the Reverse across AMERICA, where the luster is diminished - otherwise I have no idea what PCGS is talking about.  In all other respects a typical early date Walking Liberty Half in AU.  No significant marks, a scattering of the usual scuffing however a considerable amount of obvious luster remaining.  A light touch of rim toning as this spent some years in an album page; this is TONING and not whatever specious "stain" PCGS may have detected.  I can guarantee that outside this holder 95%+ of anyone looking at this could not detect a problem - the average dealer certainly would not or even mention the possibility.  Personally, I would just crack out the coin and put it into an album page - "buy the coin, not the holder".  Not a CAC coin obviously, but worthy of consideration as otherwise this is a $1,300-$1,400 coin.

PCGS 6568.97/59026918